I was lucky enough to test these alongside the ATC SCM25A Mk2 (similar price range) in my studio.
Both are fantastic speakers, but the Neumanns came out on top. The center image was clearer, and I could hear the placement and tone color of instruments much more precisely. Everything felt more defined and separated in the mix.
Honestly, I don’t think you can get anything better at this price point. For the first time, I find myself wanting to go to the studio just to sit and listen to music.
I understand why ATCs are so highly praised — they sound beautiful and musical. But if you're after maximum precision, the Neumanns are simply better.
And by the way, they don’t sound “cold” at all!